everyside
World

Muzumdar backs BCCI on trophy refusal

82 sourcesUpdated 14 Sept 2026, 5:46 am Coverage regionsGlobal · India · International · Delhi
CATCH ME UP

India’s women’s team won the final against Sri Lanka by 72 runs.

Muzumdar said the squad supports the BCCI’s decision on the trophy presentation.

He said winning the tournament matters more than the ceremony.

The decision was described as an organisational call by the BCCI.

More context

The refusal followed prior objections over the prize distribution format.

The team is now focusing on the Asian Games.

AGREEMENT VS DISAGREEMENT

What lines up. What splits.

A quick read on shared facts, changing details, and different emphasis.

What coverage agrees on

All reporting agrees that India beat Sri Lanka by 72 runs and did not accept the trophy from Mohsin Naqvi at the ceremony.

What is changing or disputed

The main dispute remains over the trophy refusal and how it was handled, while later reactions from officials and critics could add more detail.

HOW COVERAGE DIFFERS

Same story. Different emphasis.

Swipe through the perspectives. Labels describe coverage framing, not truth or quality.

Centre13

Center coverage focuses on Muzumdar’s support for the BCCI’s decision and the view that winning the title mattered more than the ceremony. It also notes that the refusal was presented as an organisational call tied to prior objections about the prize distribution format. The team’s focus has shifted to the Asian Games. One report also says the stance echoed a similar refusal by the men’s team last year.

Right1

Right-leaning coverage highlights BCCI vice-president Rajeev Shukla’s account that Mohsin Naqvi did not object when players declined the trophy. It says BCCI officials defended their professional interactions amid outside criticism. The emphasis is on Naqvi’s reaction rather than on the team’s internal decision.

Distinctive emphasis — reported claim, not independently verified.Sources: Times Now
STORY TIMELINE

How the coverage developed

The latest eight dated reports, from earliest to newest.

GO DEEPER

Read the reporting

Scan each source take, then open the original article.

The Hindu Centre source Provisional rating

Position taken by BCCI and we stand by it: Muzumdar on not accepting Asia Cup trophy from Naqvi

Quick source take

Indian women's cricket team head coach Amol Muzumdar stated that the team fully supports the BCCI's decision not to accept the Asia Cup trophy from Asian Cricket Council chief Mohsin Naqvi. Following their victory over Sri Lanka, Muzumdar emphasized that winning the tournament for a record-extending eighth time is sufficient for the players. This action mirrors a similar refusal by the Indian men's team in 2025, and Muzumdar confirmed the squad is now focusing on the upcoming Asian Games.

Rediff Centre source Reported

India refuse to accept Asia Cup trophy: 'We Stand By BCCI's Stance'

Quick source take

Indian women's cricket team head coach Amol Muzumdar publicly backed the BCCI's controversial decision to decline the winners trophy from Asian Cricket Council chief Mohsin Naqvi. After defeating Sri Lanka in the final, Muzumdar remarked that winning the tournament is enough for the team despite not receiving the physical trophy. He noted that the decision follows a precedent set by the men's team in 2025, and the squad is now preparing for the Asian Games.

The News Mill Centre source Reported

BCCI’s Saikia: Women’s Asia Cup win matters over trophy dispute

Quick source take

BCCI Secretary Devajit Saikia addressed the controversy surrounding the Women's T20 Asia Cup 2026 trophy presentation where the Indian team declined to receive the trophy from ACC chief Mohsin Naqvi. Saikia stated that winning the tournament was more important than the ceremony and clarified that the decision was an organisational one made by the BCCI due to prior objections regarding the prize distribution format. India defeated Sri Lanka by 72 runs to claim their eighth title.

The Sunday Guardian Centre source Reported

Devajit Saikia Breaks Silence on India Women’s Asia Cup Trophy Row, Explains Viral Mohsin Naqvi Interaction…

Quick source take

The Sunday Guardian reports that BCCI secretary Devajit Saikia addressed the controversy surrounding the India Women team's refusal to receive the Asia Cup trophy from ACC chairman Mohsin Naqvi after defeating Sri Lanka. Saikia stated that the decision stemmed from changed circumstances following the April 2025 Pahalgam terror attack, mirroring a similar stance taken by the men's team. He also clarified that viral footage showing cordial interactions with Naqvi in the Royal Box was merely routine match-day protocol and did not contradict the team's subsequent protest.

India Today Centre source Provisional rating

India Win Women's Asia Cup, Refuse Trophy From ACC Chief Mohsin Naqvi

Quick source take

This article reports on a road rage incident in Gurugram involving a woman biker and a car driver named Kalyan Basla. The victim's family alleged that the driver and other occupants were drunk and possessed criminal mindsets. Police registered an FIR against unknown persons for rash driving while the accused remains at large.

The Business Standard Centre source Reported

Indian women cricketers refuse Asia Cup trophy from Pakistan Cricket Board chief Naqvi

Quick source take

The Business Standard reports that the Indian women's cricket team won their eighth continental title by defeating Sri Lanka by 72 runs in Dubai, but refused to collect the trophy from Asian Cricket Council head Mohsin Naqvi. The report notes that Indian coach Amol Muzumdar stated the team stands by the decision made by the Board of Control for Cricket in India. The presentation ceremony was delayed before ending abruptly after Naqvi distributed medals only to the runners-up.

Pragativadi Centre source Reported

BCCI Explains Why India Women Refused Asia Cup Trophy From Mohsin Naqvi: ‘Solidarity’ With Men’s Team

Quick source take

Pragativadi reports that the BCCI explained the Indian women's cricket team declined to accept the Asia Cup trophy from Mohsin Naqvi to show solidarity with the men's team. According to BCCI secretary Devajit Saikia, the decision followed public pressure after the April 2025 Pahalgam terror attack, although government policy permits playing in multinational tournaments. The article notes the ceremony was delayed and India conducted its own medal presentation.

India Today Centre source Provisional rating

Naqvi did not object to India refusing Womens Asia Cup title from him, says Shukla

Quick source take

India Today reports that BCCI vice-president Rajeev Shukla stated the decision to refuse the Women's Asia Cup trophy from ACC chairman Mohsin Naqvi was a collective internal choice. Shukla noted that Naqvi did not object to the move, which echoes the men's team prior stance. BCCI secretary Devajit Saikia asserted that the action protects national interests and honors solidarity with the men's team. Shukla also dismissed criticism regarding routine interactions with Naqvi during the final.

Gulf News Centre source Reported

Rajeev Shukla explains why India refused Asia Cup trophy from Naqvi

Quick source take

Gulf News reports that BCCI Vice-President Rajeev Shukla explained that the Indian women cricket team decided not to accept the Women's Asia Cup trophy from ACC President Mohsin Naqvi following thorough discussions. India defeated Sri Lanka to secure the title, but captain Harmanpreet Kaur and teammates declined the trophy from Naqvi amidst ongoing geopolitical tensions. Shukla emphasized that there was no confrontation or quarrel during the event and dismissed criticism of officials interacting with Naqvi.

India Today Centre source Provisional rating

India won the Women's Asia Cup easily. But did they really solve their issues?

Quick source take

India won the Women's Asia Cup with dominant performances, including a 72-run win over Sri Lanka in the final. However, an analysis of the tournament highlights ongoing concerns regarding India's batting order, pace bowling options, and fielding errors. The report notes that these unresolved issues must be addressed before upcoming competitions like the Asian Games.

The Times of India Centre source Provisional rating

'Are they living in the past?': Ex-India cricketer slams Mohsin Naqvi after Asia Cup trophy snub

Quick source take

India won the Women's Asia Cup by defeating Sri Lanka by 72 runs in Dubai, but the post-match ceremony was delayed as Indian players declined to collect the trophy from Asian Cricket Council president Mohsin Naqvi. Former India cricketer Mohammad Kaif questioned Naqvi's ability to balance cricket administration with his political commitments in Pakistan. The incident echoed a similar refusal during the men's Asia Cup final last year.

Hindustan Times Centre source Provisional rating

BCCI reveals Mohsin Naqvi’s reaction after India refused Asia Cup trophy from him: 'He did not raise any…

Quick source take

Following the Indian women's cricket team's victory in the Asia Cup final against Sri Lanka, players refused to accept the trophy from ACC chief Mohsin Naqvi. BCCI vice-president Rajeev Shukla stated that Naqvi did not raise any objections to the collective decision made by the Indian board. BCCI officials explained that the move was intended to show solidarity with the men's team's stance from the previous year.

Greater Kashmir Centre source Reported

PM Modi congratulates Indian Women’s Cricket Team on winning Asia Cup

Quick source take

Prime Minister Narendra Modi congratulated the Indian Women's Cricket Team on winning the Asia Cup. He praised the team's confidence, consistency, and remarkable spirit throughout the tournament. Modi expressed hope that this triumph will inspire millions of youngsters across the country.

Times Now Right source Reported

Asia Cup Trophy Row: BCCI Reveals Mohsin Naqvi’s Reaction To India’s Refusal

Quick source take

BCCI vice-president Rajeev Shukla confirmed that PCB chief Mohsin Naqvi did not object after Indian players refused to accept the Women's Asia Cup final trophy from him in Dubai. India secured a 72-run victory over Sri Lanka to claim the title. Shukla and other BCCI officials defended their professional interactions with Naqvi amid criticism from observers.